Sixpence None the Richer Bassist Justin Cary Dies at 50 After Stroke

Justin Cary, the bassist who joined Sixpence None the Richer in 1997, died on June 18, 2026, at Albany Medical Center in New York. He was 50 and had been hospitalized after suffering a stroke that required two surgeries and intensive‑care treatment.

Cary’s death was confirmed by the band’s members. Matt Slocum, co‑founder and guitarist, posted a statement on social media that read: “We are completely heartbroken. The depth of our grief proves the depth of our love for this wonderful man who was our bandmate, brother‑in‑arms, and friend for 30 years.” Leigh Nash, the lead singer, added: “We sure had a great time. Thank you, Justin. We love you forever. Please keep his dear wife Linda close to your hearts. She is our family.” The statements were shared on the band’s official channels.

Born June 21, 1975, Cary grew up in upstate New York before moving to Nashville in 1997, the same year he replaced bassist J.J. Plasencio. His arrival coincided with the release of the band’s self‑titled album, which produced the hit “Kiss Me.” The single peaked at No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100 and earned a Grammy nomination for Best Pop Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocals. The album itself received a nomination for Best Rock Gospel Album.

Cary’s bass work is heard on the recordings that defined the group’s mainstream breakthrough, including the covers of “There She Goes” and “Don’t Dream It’s Over.” He remained with the band through its 2004 split and returned for the 2017 reunion tour, participating in the recording of new material and international shows. In 2023 the band released the single “The Tide,” followed by “We Are Love” and the “Rosemary Hill” EP in 2024.

Outside of Sixpence None the Richer, Cary built a career as a session and touring musician. He performed with Counting Crows, Paul Brandt, and Lee Brice, among others. On his personal website he frequently reflected on the realities of life in the music industry and his desire to keep learning through performance and travel.

Cary’s death comes at a time when the band’s classic lineup is active again. The group’s recent releases and touring schedule had been built around the chemistry that developed over nearly three decades of collaboration. According to the band’s statements, the loss of Cary will affect future plans, though no official announcement has been made regarding replacements or changes to upcoming shows.

The obituary was reported by several outlets, including Rolling Stone, Variety, and the Associated Press. All reports confirmed the stroke as the cause of death and noted the band’s tribute posts. No additional medical details were released.

The band’s members and fans have expressed grief on social media, with many recalling Cary’s steady presence and musicianship. The band’s official website now includes a memorial page for Cary, and a GoFundMe campaign was set up to support his wife Linda and family.

Justin Cary’s contributions to Sixpence None the Richer’s most commercially successful era have secured his place in the group’s legacy. His death marks the end of a nearly 30‑year tenure that helped shape the sound of late‑1990s alternative pop.

The current situation is that the band has paused touring to mourn Cary, and no definitive statement has been issued regarding future performances. Fans and industry observers will likely await further updates from the group’s management.